### Dear Carrie,

###### Question: What are the differences among the Algebra 1 choices for 9th grade math?

Dear Carrie,

We’ve enjoyed using Heart of Dakota for many years, and we are getting ready to start 9th grade high school! I’m hoping you can help me weigh the pros and cons of the Algebra 1 choices for math. My son will be in 9th grade and in the *World Geography* guide this year. He finished all of the *Singapore Math* through 7th grade. In 8th grade, he did *Principles of Mathematics Book 2*. I’m trying to decide which program to go with next. Could you tell me from your experiences what you saw as pros and cons of each for 9th grade? Thanks so much!

Sincerely,

“Ms. Help Me Choose the Best Algebra 1 for My 9th Grade Son”

###### Dear “Ms. Help Me Choose the Best Algebra 1 for My 9th Grade Son,”

For 9th grade, I did *VideoText Algebra* for our oldest son, *Foerster’s Algebra* for our second son, and *mathhelp.com* (yourteacher.com) for Algebra with our third son. Our oldest son also did *No-Nonsense Algebra* prior to beginning *VideoText* *Algebra*, just because I wasn’t sure where to go next with him in the 8th grade. So, we’ve actually done all the programs we recommend.

###### Each Algtebra 1 math program has its positives.

Each Algebra 1 math program is different from the others, and each program has its positives. *No-Nonsense* is definitely a shorter, no-frills Algebra program. It is for the 9th grade math student who struggles with math. *VideoText Algebra* is either for a motivated, independent student or for a student whose parent has time to be involved in the program daily. *Foerster’s* is a more challenging program especially in the area of word problems.

###### There are a few differences in each of the math Algebra 1 programs.

*Foerster’s Algebra 1 *requires a strong, independent math student. I did not help my 9th grade oldest son with *VideoText Algebra*. He got through it, but it took longer than anticipated. This was due to the fact that he is a perfectionist and wouldn’t move on until he had mastered the material. I helped my second son with *Foerster’s Algebra I*. We did not use the videos and just went over the lesson in the book together. Then, my son worked the problems with some oversight from me. When he later moved into *Foerster’s Algebra II* with the videos, he was able to do his math on his own. I helped my third son in 9th grade this past year with http://www.mathhelp.com. We went over the videos and examples together.

###### I determined I needed to be more involved in helping with* Algebra 1* as needed.

After losing track of my oldest son’s math, I determined that I needed to be involved in helping the rest of the boys with their math. I will say that my oldest son did fine doing math on his own, but I wasn’t able to help him if he needed help. This left me feeling out-of-touch. So, I became more involved with my later boys.

###### Each of the math programs prepared our sons well for their future math needs.

Each of the programs do a good job of helping kiddos get through math. My sons have varying abilities when it comes to math, and they have all done fine with the programs they have used. Our oldest son was able to test out of most of his algebra quickly for ACE credit which his college accepted. Our second son was able to CLEP out of College Mathematics after doing a quick refresher course. So, we feel good about the math choices we recommend. They do a great job of preparing kiddos for their future math needs. I hope this helps!

Blessings,

Carrie

P.S. If you are new to Heart of Dakota, check out our Top 10 Questions!